What shall we do to these men? — The question now debated was clearly one that never ought to have been even asked. They were sitting as a Court of Justice, and should have given their verdict for or against the accused according to the evidence. They abandon that office, and begin discussing what policy was most expedient. It was, we may add, characteristic of Caiaphas to do so (John 11:49-50).
A notable miracle. — Literally, sign.
We cannot deny it. — The very form of the sentence betrays the will, though there is not the power.